What’s New? Natural Bordeaux! #Winophiles

Chateau Siaurac in Lalande de Pomerol

SO much tradition in Bordeaux. Can there be anything new under the sun?

Winophiles Dig for What’s New in Bordeaux
January 2021 brings our French Winophiles group back to Bordeaux, looking around for something new from the region. We have lots of great ideas, just look at the list of links farther down in this post!

Château Phélan-Ségur winery

Yes, a candle is still the best means of watching for sediment

Bordeaux Fame and Tradition
The Bordeaux wine region is perhaps the most famous in the world. As such, it isn’t exactly a hotbed of innovation or revolution. We can’t blame them, the top wines from the region were exalted for the World’s Fair in the Classification of 1855. Ever since, those top wines have maintained their reputations and prices and today, they dare not take a big risk on something new and different. The approach is to make the absolute best tasting wine possible, the winemaker is seen as something of a chef, using selections among several grapes, multiple plots, different barrels for “spice” to craft a wine of elegance, ready to age nearly indefinitely.

Even in the difficult climate, some Bordeaux châteaux have embraced organic and biodynamic techniques

Organic, Biodynamic and Natural Wines – in Bordeaux?
The larger world of wine consumers have a growing interest in foods and wines relying on fewer chemicals, organic, biodynamic and even natural wines fit the bill. Bordeaux has several challenges with these approaches. First and foremost – the region has a maritime climate, it’s only a few miles to the Atlantic ocean, plus the Gironde estuary, Garonne and Dordogne rivers run through. It can rain anytime all year. This is a nightmare for organic viticulture, since synthetic chemicals aren’t allowed and even the allowed traditional treatments are strictly controlled in how much can be used. Even so, some of the highest ranking wineries have transitioned to organic or biodynamic viticulture. It’s not easy, but consumer interest is strong and winemakers find the results are worth the effort.

Natural Wines – Taking Non-Intervention to the Extreme
Natural wine is a topic which generates high emotions on both pro- and con- sides. Stepping away from the arguing, here are the key features embraced by most practitioners

  • Certified organic or biodynamic viticulture
  • Hand harvest
  • No sulfur dioxide applied to the grapes until bottling
  • Native yeasts
  • No nutrients, corrections, acidification, tannin additions, no harsh mechanical interventions
  • Intent is nothing added, nothing removed.
  • No or minimal sulfur dioxide at bottling

After all that work in the vineyard, natural winemakers throw all the (chemical) tools to reduce risk, speed progress and allow corrections to be made in the cellar – away. Rather than hands-off, this is highly involved winemaking. Scrupulous attention must be paid to cleanliness in the winery and the wine’s development must be carefully watched. Winemakers who are committed to this approach believe this is the truest expression of the vintage and the place.

The Amoreau family at Château le Puy make very traditional Right Bank Bordeaux wines that happen to be natural wine.

Natural Wine in Bordeaux: Chateau le Puy
Château le Puy has been farmed by the Amoreau family since 1610. Humorously described as being chemical-free forever, they explain it was because they were “cheap”! In any case, they have been committed to a minimal intervention approach since long before it was popular. They are Demeter certified and have been farming biodynamically since the 1960’s. They stopped adding sulfites or any other additives to their wines since at least 1990. Today, they add a small amount at bottling to ensure long term stability. The amount they add is well below the allowed limit for biodynamic wines and is sufficiently low to qualify for their wines to be presented at Isabelle Legeron’s Raw Wine fairs.

Château le Puy Francs Côtes de Bordeaux “Emilien” 2016 (locally $60 or online here) 13%abv
85% Merlot, 7% cabernet franc, 6% cabernet sauvignon, 1% malbec and 1% carménère, matured in oak barrels and casks for 24 months.

Eye: medium garnet
Nose: medium plus intensity aromas of ripe blueberries, blackberries, black plums, clean earth, pine needles, dried leaves, a bit of barnyard, balsamic vinegar.
Mouth: dry with medium plus acidity, medium plus velvety tannins, medium plus body, medium alcohol and a long finish. Medium plus intensity flavors of ripe blueberries, blackberries, black plums, clean earth, pine needles, dried leaves, a bit of barnyard, balsamic vinegar.
Observations: A very nice wine, typical of wines from the Côtes de Bordeaux in that it is drinking very nicely right now, no need to let it age for a long time. A bit rustic due to the barnyard and balsamic, but very enjoyable for those who like that slightly funky earthy character.

Duc des Nauves Vin de France 2018 (locally $28 or online here) 12.5% abv
The Amoreau family acquired this nine-hectare vineyard in 2006, and immediately began employing biodynamic practices (Duc des Nauves is certified biodynamic as of the 2015 vintage). Planted to 70% Merlot, 20% Cabernet Franc, and 10% Cabernet Sauvignon, In the cellar, Duc des Nauves is both fermented (spontaneously, of course) and aged in cement, and bottled without filtration after one year.

Eye: medium ruby
Nose: medium intensity aromas of ripe blueberries, blackberries, black plums, clean earth, a bit of barnyard initially but it blows off after an hour or so.
Mouth: Dry, medium plus acidity, medium plus chalky tannins, medium body, medium alcohol, medium plus savory finish. Medium intensity flavors of ripe blueberries, blackberries, black plums, forest floor, rosemary.
Observations: Not quite as much intensity or complexity as the flagship wine, this is still very enjoyable, clearly showing a traditional approach.

Curious about Natural Wine – in Bordeaux and Beyond?
Isabelle Legeron MW (Master of Wine) is the best known vocal proponent for natural wine worldwide. She wrote an excellent book on the subject, Natural Wine. She explains the ethos of the whole concept, the agreed techniques and supplies a good list of wineries to investigate all over the world. In addition, she organizes a natural wine fair, Raw Wine, which has grown to a large fair drawing an international audience of both winemakers, buyers and enthusiasts. The Raw Wine website includes a searchable list of wineries that show at Raw Wine.  Isabelle’s fair isn’t for the “zero sulfur at all costs” crowd, the fair has guidelines and requires wineries to post the figures. The searchable database is a great way to find wines to try, Château le Puy is here, and their Duc des Nauves is here. You never know who you might run into while searching this list.

If you’re interested in top quality low intervention in general (organic, biodynamic and natural), Jane Anson’s Wine Revolution is an excellent resource. Jane is a respected writer for Decanter and other media, and Wine Revolution profiles wineries worldwide pursuing these techniques.  If you’re not quite ready to plunge into natural wines, Jane covers an extensive list of organic and biodynamic winegrowers.

We enjoyed our wines with coq au vin (rouge). I always double the onions and mushrooms. How about you?

Winophiles Tackle What’s New in Bordeaux
And you thought there was nothing new going on in Bordeaux! Take a look below at all the great ideas from our French Winophiles group. Join our chat on twitter: Saturday, Jan. 16  10-11 am CST at #Winophiles. See you then!



21 Responses to “What’s New? Natural Bordeaux! #Winophiles”
  1. culinarycam says:

    So true what you said about Château le Puy. I remember explaining ‘organic’ to a friend who had just immigrated from Ecuador. She was astounded. “In Ecuador we farm organic because we’re poor. Only the rich farmers can afford chemicals.” Thanks for hosting this month. Sorry that I was off in left field a bit.

  2. advinetures says:

    Another insightful article and loved the resources you provided as this is a topic that really deserves research to understand the challenges and points of view both for and against. We’ve found that discussions around Natural wine certainly make for lively ones depending on personal views!

    • Thanks Allison and Chris. If you really want to understand from the vineyard and winemaking side, Britt and Per Karlsson’s book on Organic, Biodynamic and Natural Winemaking book is very good and even-handed.

  3. Love the comment about being too “cheap” for chemicals. I also tasted a Francs Côtes de Bordeaux and found it highly drinkable right now. Thanks for the topic – learned a lot!

  4. Agreed the RAW wine website is such a great resources! Love the event in 2019, and look forward to attending again in the After Time. PS I’m not big on onions so they are always halved in recipes and with mushrooms we usually sue all that we have!

  5. Nicole Ruiz Hudson says:

    That coq au vin look amazing and such a cozy scene with the wines and the fire! Great info on organic, biodynamic, and natural wines in BDX. I think I’ll have to check out these books.

  6. I’m slowly dipping into the natural wine pool and like what I’ve found. Eager to try more bottles from Bordeaux, given the challenges faced by vignerons in this region. Great topic this month!

    • Thanks Lauren. You might especially like Jane’s book. It’s not exclusively natural wines, but really top wines in the low intervention style around the world with more in depth interviews, too.

  7. Lynn says:

    The benefits of being cheap! I didn’t know the history of the Amoreau family, thanks for the tidbits and a great article Jeff. Definitely double both!

    We went to Raw Wine London in 2019, fantastic. If you get a chance, definitely go.

    • Thanks Lynn. I hope to be able to go to either Raw Wine or one of the smaller fairs like that sometime. I’ve been to the Vignerons Independant in Lyon twice, what fun!

  8. wendyklik says:

    Thanks so much for hosting Jeff. I was glad to be able to participate.

  9. Lisa Denning says:

    Jeff, great and informative article. Chateau le Puy is to be commended for their role in biodynamic wine production in Bordeaux, even if it started because they were “too cheap!”

  10. robincgc says:

    I love the suggestions for further reading! There are a couple of books I will look up! Thanks Jeff!

Check out what others are saying...
  1. […] Jeff at Food Wine Click! declares What’s New? Natural Bordeaux! […]

  2. […] Jeff atFood Wine Click! shares “What’s New? Natural Bordeaux!” […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: